Different Approaches to Council in Contemporary Arab Political Thought

Document Type : Conceptual paper (Political Thought)


Associate professor of political sciences faculty at Imam Sadiq University


The political thought of the contemporary Arab thinkers can be formulated in the relation between tradition and modernity. Struggle with modernity and return to the tradition of the Salafist minds, the possibility of rejuvenation of tradition by some other intellectual thinkers, the acceptance of modernity and putting the tradition aside, and the combination and compromise between tradition and modernity, are various forms of this ratiometric that can be beneficial in understanding the political thought of many contemporary Arab thinkers among the Sunni community. Meanwhile, the Council is a key word considered by many scholars from different Sunni countries, especially in the post-Ottoman Empire era, a good starting point for achieving a desirable political system. The type of impression of these thinkers from the council and the meaning given to this key sign from different perspectives, forms the mindset of many of these thinkers: reducing the meaning of council to the level of consultation and monistic view of it, the unanimity of the council with the resolution and community, the belief in the council as a society of Muslim citizens and the Islamic Ummah, and the promotion of the council from democracy are different aspects of contemporary thinkers. The result of this new look can be found in the neglect of the capacity of tradition, including the council, to systematize politics in the modern era with a thinker such as Ali Abdul Raziq, an attempt to revive the council in the new caliph-lovers, such as young Rashid Reza, and the link between Shura(council) and democracy in the moderate school of eastern scholars such as Rashid Reza Pir, Gharzavin and Ghonoushi, and finally believing in the superiority of the council to democracy under Mohammad Tofigh al-Shavi. This paper, by a documentary method, and expressing conceptual framework and different narrations of the concept of the council, seeks to reconsider the position of the council to the aforementioned thinkers.


Main Subjects

Al-alheidar, Heidar. Wilayat al-Faqih and shūrā, (1988). Bija Complex of Islamic Thought, First Edition
Alikhani, Seddiqi. “Rachid Ghannouchi’s Political Thought in Political Thought of Muslem Philosophers” (2011). Vol. 18. Institute for Social and Cultural Studies
Al-Shavi, Towfiq Mohammad. The General Theory of Council(1992). Second edition, al-qāhira, Dar Al Wafaa Printing & pub.
Al-Shavi, Towfiq Mohammad. Al - Shuri is on top of the democratic hierarchy (1995), al-qāhira, Dar Al - Zahraa Arab Media
Basheer Nafi, Musa. The Islamists (2012). Translated by Seyyed Qasem Zakeri. Institute for Political and International Studies. In association with The Institute for Compilation and Publication of Imam Khomeini’s Works
Bashiriyeh, Hossein (1999). Transition to Democracy. Negahe Mo’aser pub.
Black, Anthony (2006), The History of Islamic Political Thought, translated by Muhammad Husein Waqar, Institute of information
Bohrani, Morteza.  Islam and Democracy in Youssef Al Gharzavi’s Political Thought (2011). Tried by Aliakbar Khani. Institute for Social and Cultural Studies.
Dehkhoda, Aliakbar, Dictionary, vol. 10, p. 14550, Second Edition of new period , Uni. of Tehran Press
Feirahi, Davood. Political System and State in Islam (2006). SAMT pub, 4th edition
Feirahi, Davood. Theory of Council (2009). TOWFIQ MOHAMMAD, AL-SHAVI. Political quarterly, Journal of Political science and law faculty, vol. 39, num, 1. Spring
Ghazizadeh, Kazem.The position of the council in the Islamic government (2005).Tehran: Orouj pub  
Golmohammadi, Ali. Rashid Reza in Political Thought of Muslem philosophers” (2011). Vol. 11. Institute for Social and Cultural Studies   
Al-Dīnawarī, Ibn Qutayba. al-Imāma wal-Siyāsa (2001). Translated by Naser Tabatabaei. Qoqnoos pub. Bashiriyeh, Hossein. Lessons on Democracy for Everyone, Tehran, Negha-e-moaasar, 2001
Khadduri, Majid. Political Revival of Islam: from Seyyed Jamal to the  al-Ikhwān al-Muslimīn(1980). Ahamadi, Hamid. Tehran: Elham
Mir-Ahmadi, Mansour. Islam and Advisory Democracy in Tehran (2005). Nashreney Pub.
Qazizadeh, Kazem (2005). The Position of Council in Islamic Government. Tehran: Orouj pub.
Rashid Reza, Muhammad. (Bi ta Alef), al-wahy al-muhammadi, Egypt, Bina pub.
Rashid Reza, Muhammad. (Bi ta Be), alkhlafah a’ou alimamah ala’thma, Study and presentation of Wajeeheh Kutrani, Beirut, Dar Al Tali’ah    
Rachid Ghonoushi’s. Public Freedoms in Islamic Government (2002). Translated by Hosein Saberi. Elmifarhangi pub
Sayyid Ali Hosseini Milani. The role of council in Imamate (2010). Trans. And edited by editorial board of alhaqaeq islamic center of Qom
Qaderi, Hatam.  Theories of the Caliphate (1996). Bonyan pub. First edition          
Central Unit of News /Politics (09.11.2011 )
Central Unit of News/Politics (09.11.2011)
Volume 1, Issue 2
October 2014
Pages 1-31
  • Receive Date: 16 April 2018
  • Revise Date: 17 May 2018
  • Accept Date: 27 May 2018